Anarchy in the Laboratory ( and the Role of the State ) ∗

A recent literature on the economics of conflict has provided conditions under which an “anarchic” outcome may come to serve as an equilibrium for an economy, as well as conditions under which a “dictator” or “government agent” is empowered to make collective action choices that enable the economy to achieve a Pareto superior equilibrium. This paper reports results from a laboratory experiment designed to test the predictions of this theory. We find that in the absence of any government, groups of subjects choose forecasts and actions that lie within a neighborhood of the predicted anarchic equilibrium, where some players choose to be producers, while others choose to be predators. The introduction of the government agent, charged with maximizing the consumption of producers, enables the subject groups to achieve nearly perfect coordination on a Pareto superior Nash equilibrium, where the fraction of time devoted to defense is high, but predation is eliminated. JEL Classification Nos. D60, D70, D83.